Astroparticle Physics Forum COSMOVIA

Small thesis of Alena Mufazalova

Dear Maxim Yuryevich,
I have only small part of my thesis but I'd like to present solution to question about masses of quarks. I will present full version soon.

Dear Alena,
Thank you for your draft, but I cannot put you more than 4-/5 as your Intermediate control mark with high estimation of your efforts, but there are a lot of English Grammar errors in your text.
Please find attached the text with my corrections
I look forward to your corrected and translated English text
With the best regards
M.Yu.Khlopov

Dear Maxim Yurevich,

My second version in attached file

Dear Alena,
Thank you. My comments are in the attached file. I have underlined without comment expressions and terms that should be corrected. Please add discussion of freezing out of pions and nucleons and mirror nucleosynthesis.
What kinds of mirror nuclei are formed? Pay special attention to pion atoms – negative charged pion is bound with nuclei much earlier, than recombination with mirror electrons takes place.
With the best regards
M.Yu.Khlopov

Dear Maxim Yurievich,

My next version of small thesis.
I'm not quite sure what I should correct in the comments "this is an additional assumption ". Does it mean I shoud not consider other effects based on them in my model? I also decided to consider the charge-symmetric world and leave my past estimates.

Dear Alena,
It is your model and you can add assumptions to enrich its physics.
But all the assumptions should be stipulated
My comments are in the attached file
With the best regards
M.Yu.Khlopov

Dear Maxim Yurievich,

Thank you for your answer, I tried to take into account all the comments and recalculated the parameters of freeze out.

Dear Alena,
My comments are in the attached file. Still make a choice - do you have mirror baryosynthesis or charge symmetric mirror baryon world? please make more accurate calculations of freeze out abundances - you have evidently missed numerical factors in the rate of expansion.
With the best regards
M.Yu.Khlopov

Dear Alena,
The self-consistent treatment of your model involves:
1. Your quarks and leptons are massless. On that reason you don't have problem of CP violation in mirror QCD and don't need mirror PQ symmetry
2. The mass of mirror hadrons is determined by confinement. For one family its scale differs from ususl QCD - please estimate its value in your case
With the best regards
M.Yu.Khlopov