Astroparticle Physics Forum COSMOVIA

Dear Maxim, thank you very much for your reply. I choose the second proposition, to continue to improve my text. Can you tell me how long time I have to finish to correct my text ?

With my best regards

Steve

Dear Steve,
The timescale depends on your efforts.
To reach the sufficiently good level of your text, you should demonstrate much deeper understanding of the problem, since we consider it as a draft for Introduction to your future PhD thesis.
During this week I'll put on Forum my recommendations for your further work
With the best regards
Maxim

Dear Maxim, this the last version of my referat. I changed some sentences in the introduction, the section 2, 5.2, 5.3 and 6.1. I will correct the bibliography later. Please tell me your opinion about this version.

Best regards

Steve

Dear Steve,
You should very seriously work on academic style. Statements like 'scientists conclude' should not be present.
I marked yellow statements and sentences to be corrected.
You should add discussion of OHe atomic structure and dark atom explanation of high energy positron excess (adding also two-component dark atom model in discussion).
And of course references should be put in proper form
With the best regards
M.Yu.Khlopov

Dear Maxim, this is my referat with the last corrections. About the bibliography, there are some references I took in some papers which have no informations about the title, the journal, and arXiv. Do you think I have to remove this references ?

Best regards

Steve

Dear Steve,
My comments are in the attached file.
With the best regards
M.Yu.Khlopov

Dear Maxim, this my referat with the corrections. Please tell me your opinion about it.

Best regards,

Steve

Dear Steve,
My comments are in the attached file. I have put there some questions in my comments, which need very serious analysis and should be answered properly to prove your ability to work on future thesis.
With the best regards
M.Yu.Khlopov

Dear Maxim, this my referat with my last corrections. Thank you for all your comments and advices.

Best regards

Steve

Dear Steve,
My comments are in the attached file. Misprints are marked yellow.
Please put all the pages and volumes in references
With the best regards
Maxim